June 1, 2021
A shy 12-year-old runs for seventh grade representative against a popular mean girl. Rachel Levin-Lopez, a White-presenting Latinx girl, has two very overprotective moms. Before Rachel was even born, Mom and Mami had lost another daughter to a tragic accident, so now she's the only seventh grader who's not allowed to walk to school alone. But for the first time, timid Rachel has friends: the Spyglass Sisterhood--ordinary Ellie, who is White; blunt and brilliant Kiara, who is Black; and sarcastic goth Alyssa, who is of South Asian descent. She and her friends have discovered that the telescope in Ellie's house sometimes reveals people's wishes and fears. Despite this magical element, the plot is grounded in familiar middle-grade themes; it serves mostly as a frame for a series of events in which Rachel finds a lost dog and gains some confidence. Kiara has nominated a reluctant Rachel to be the class representative, as her ideas for the role really are pretty great. With some cheerleading from the sisterhood, Rachel learns to speak up for herself at home and school both. The dialogue often reads far more like an adult's than a 12-year-old's, and Rachel's opponent is cartoonishly vapid, but overall it's a decent character arc--and Rachel gets to keep the dog. The characters' diversity is mostly superficial; racial identity is not plumbed. Pleasant enough. (Fantasy. 9-11)
COPYRIGHT(2021) Kirkus Reviews, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
March 25, 2022
Gr 3-6-The second installment of the "Spyglass Sisterhood" series features Rachel Levin-Lopez, a seventh grader who lives with her two mothers, whom she calls Mom and Mami. Rachel thinks of herself as a shy person and struggles with finding her voice. Told in first person, this novel centers Rachel and her closest friends Ellie, Alyssa, and Kiara, who are all able to see through a spyglass that is located in Ellie's old Victorian house's turret. The spyglass allows the diverse group of girls, who call themselves The Sisterhood, to see the hopes, aspirations, and worries of themselves and others. In this entry, Rachel is nominated to run for class representative, and she's campaigning against the most popular girl in seventh grade. Along the way, Rachel finds a dog, whom she comes to love, but knows that she must attempt to find its original owner. A running theme throughout is the impact of lying and lies of omission. Beautifully honest and realistic, despite the spyglass, this book delivers big on many emotions and typical middle school life. VERDICT A great purchase for most middle grade collections. Highly recommended.-Tracy Cronce
Copyright 2022 School Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.