September 21, 2015
Penelope always gets good grades, irons her bed sheets each morning, rewrites her notes during recess, and stays up late writing lists. When she oversleeps one morning, she arrives late at school with frazzled hair and mismatched clothes, and she earns her first B. In a quick (and unprompted) transformation, Penelope starts to laugh, realizing that the world won’t end if she lets her hair down once in a while. Anderson’s singsong rhymes make the story’s message plain (“I’ve learned not to make life a checklist./ That doesn’t mean that I’m lazy./ It’s all right to go with the flow sometimes,/ And not make myself so crazy”) and Kath injects plenty of humor into her cartooning as their biracial heroine models a valuable attitude for readers whose striving can tilt into anxiety. Ages 5–9.
December 1, 2015
K-Gr 2-Penelope is a perfectionist who needs to have everything exactly right. She never makes mistakes and spends a lot of time and energy maintaining her persona. One day, her alarm does not go off, and Penelope's life is turned upside down. She is unable to prepare with her usual fervor, and her day veers wildly off track. At first, she is upset by this detour from her routine, but she soon finds that relaxing her strict rules to have a little fun can be enjoyable. The rhyming text moves the narrative along effectively, and Penelope's quirks are charming. The illustrations enhance the story; initially they are very orderly, but after Penelope's alarm clock mishap they reflect the commotion she's feeling. The depiction of Penelope's diverse classmates and her biracial family is refreshing. There is supplemental material included for adults who wish to use this story as a teaching tool. VERDICT Those who have issues similar to Penelope's will appreciate this title. Recommended for parents and teachers looking to help kids struggling with perfectionism.-Ellen Norton, Naperville Public Library, Naperville, IL
Copyright 2015 School Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.
Penelope tries hard to be, as the title indicates, perfect. Penelope Perfect appears proud of her nickname, inspired by her discipline: "Have you ever heard of Old Faithful? / Well, that geyser has nothin' on me!" Continuing in pedestrian verse, Penelope catalogs the course of her day: she cleans her room, exercises, then gets on the bus. At school, Penelope arranges her desk and rechecks her work. She doesn't even take a break at lunch, staying in to rewrite her notes. Cheery cartoons that vary from double-page spreads to full-page illustrations and vignettes show her many instances of perfection, even into the night, when she gets under the covers with a flashlight to double-check her list. On occasion, she appears concerned, but more often she wears a contented smile. But one morning, she wakes up late, throwing off her routine and initially causing great consternation. To Penelope's surprise-and everyone else's-she feels oddly free and even takes part in the games at recess. She's changed by the experience. Unfortunately, the message is mixed, given Penelope's previous self-satisfaction and the fact that, even reformed, she refers to play as "goofing off." The book concludes with four pages of activities and discussion questions to help adults understand and work with children struggling with perfectionism. Penelope's African-American mom and Caucasian dad are a nice touch. It's not perfect, but it means well. (Picture book. 5-8) COPYRIGHT(1) Kirkus Reviews, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.