March 1, 2009
Gr 6-8-Vandals have crossed off the "o" and the "n" from the welcome sign outside the town of Moundville, and appropriately so, as it's been raining there continually for 22 years. Shortly after 12-year-old Roy discovers that he'll be sharing his bedroom with Sturgis, a scarred foster child about his age, the rain stops. What better opportunity to organize some baseball? In short order Roy finds himself captaining a ragtag team with himself as catcher, Sturgiswho has a wicked fastballon the mound, and position players of both sexes with wildly varying levels of skill. Scaletta takes nearly 80 pages to trot out his varied, well-drawn supporting cast and to fill in the town's history (a necessity: that rain interrupted an important baseball game that some adults, at least, still regard as unfinished business), but he balances perceptive explorations of personal and domestic issues perfectly with fine baseball talk and (eventually) absorbing play-by-play. Readers will cheer Roy on as he struggles to get his team in shape, clicks with a girl who is new to the game but turns out to have an unhittable natural screwball, and weathers some rough waters with moody Sturgis on the way to a rousing climax and a fitting resolution.John Peters, New York Public Library
Copyright 2009 School Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.
March 1, 2009
Grades 4-8 Thosewho dont know an RBI from an ERA should look elsewhere, but for readers who eat and sleep sports, Scalettas debut is a gift from the baseball gods.It centers on 12-year-oldRoy McGuire, whose dreams of being a major leaguer are literally dampened by the fact that it has been raining in his hometownfor 22 years. The rain began during a contest with neighboring Sinister Bend, and it ends right after Roy returns from baseball camp to find a new foster brother, Sturgis, living at his house. Their relationship is rocky, but no one can deny Sturgis throwing power, and soon both boys are ramping up for an epic rematch between the two towns. Various asides and in-jokesmake clear that Scaletta is steeped not only in baseball lore but in such movie classics as The Natural and Field of Dreams, and that sort of larger-than-life magic realism lends his story the aura of a proper tall tale. Sports nuts, including reluctant readers, will sense they are in good hands with this one.(Reprinted with permission of Booklist, copyright 2009, American Library Association.)
July 1, 2009
It's been raining in Moundville for twenty-two years. When the sun miraculously comes out, twelve-year-old baseball lover Roy assembles a scrappy team, including the surly and mysterious foster kid Roy's father invited into their home. As the "Mudville Nine" resurrect the soaked baseball field, they bring life to a whole town. Through his cast of memorable characters, Scaletta's baseball enthusiasm shines.
(Copyright 2009 by The Horn Book, Incorporated, Boston. All rights reserved.)
July 1, 2009
With references throughout to Ernest Thayer's "Casey at the Bat," this humorous and tender ode to baseball is as full of hope and suspense as Casey's famous turn at bat. It has been raining in the town of Moundville for twenty-two years; if that's not bad enough, nothing else in twelve-year-old Roy's life has given him much reason for optimism. His mother is absent save for drunken phone calls and the occasional postcard, and his father has invited a surly and mysterious foster kid, Sturgis, into their home. Roy knows that "you learn pretty young not to start planting sunflowers just because the rain lets up a little." But when the sun comes out and the rain miraculously stops, baseball-lover Roy assembles a scrappy team and coaches them to play Sinister Bend, Moundville's archrivals. Through a cast of memorable characters -- one kid is called Google because the only phrase he seems to know in English is "search me" -- Scaletta's enthusiasm for the sport shines. As the "Mudville Nine" resurrect the soaked baseball field, they bring life to a whole town. Though Roy's maturity at times seems beyond his age and experience, he is still an engaging narrator. Baseball fans or not, readers will sympathize with Sturgis for his painful past and root for Roy and his team to win the big game.
(Copyright 2009 by The Horn Book, Incorporated, Boston. All rights reserved.)