August 5, 2013
When 16-year-old Ann's aunt and longtime partner announce they are getting married in two months, the size 17 teenager decides, "I'll need to lose forty-five pounds. By the middle of August." First, she turns to a line of expensive (and gross-tasting) products she saw in an infomercial. But when her impressionable little sister, Libby, develops dangerous eating habits, Ann opts to be a more positive role modelâafter all, "eating shouldn't be a punishment." Characters are often overly scripted, such as Ann's small-minded step-grandmother and Libby, who tells her teddy bear, "No more cake for you. You are too fat already." However, Ann's frank tone and levelheaded attitude should evoke compassion and understanding. First-time novelist Barson urges readers to think critically about women's obsession with food, diets, and weight, as well as societal prejudice directed at large people. When Ann's mother makes a snide comment about an overweight couple at a fast food restaurant, Ann thinks, "So what if they eat here everyday?.... Are they hurting anyone?" Ages 12âup. Agent: Sara Crowe, Harvey Klinger.
June 1, 2013
Ann has a weight problem and a mother problem--and the two issues are likely connected. A rising high school junior, Ann has fought (and lost) the weight battle since early childhood. Getting hilariously stuck in a too-small dress she tries on at the mall surely proves it. She clearly has a dysfunctional relationship with food, eating way too much whenever she's troubled--which is to say quite often--and blithely rationalizing her behavior. Unwisely determined to lose 45 pounds in two months in order to look good in a bridesmaid's dress when her aunt marries her girlfriend, Ann buys a diet program from an infomercial. Her account of suffering horrendous exercise videos and bad food is both funny and sad, and she falls off the wagon several times. She and her thin, driven mother don't, at first glance, seem to have much in common. But when Ann sees her 4-year-old stepsister telling her teddy bear he's too fat, she realizes both she and her mom have serious food issues that threaten her sister's well-being. That recognition, presented in an authentic first-person voice, gradually paves the way for believable changes as Ann re-evaluates failed friendships, her own role in consuming secretly spiked drinks at a party, and the potential for a relationship with a nice--and attractive--guy. While lessons are offered, they are deliciously coated in readable prose and a compelling plot. (Fiction. 12 & up)
COPYRIGHT(2013) Kirkus Reviews, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
July 1, 2013
Gr 8-10-Sixteen-year-old Ann has a big problem. She has just two months to get into a bridesmaid dress for her Aunt Jackie's wedding. She needs to lose 45 pounds, which would be hard enough without the complications of a new job, a cute boy, a mean group of girls, and blended families that leave her caught in the middle-and left out. Her mother is obsessive about her own weight and as the summer wears on, Ann begins to see just how troubled her families are. Telling the story in Ann's wry, realistic voice, this debut author effectively captures society's preoccupation with size and the resulting alienation of an overweight teen. With a chain-smoking grandmother whose language is peppered with "fat-ass," relatives and friends who are slyly disparaging about her weight, and a mother who constantly prods her about dieting, the message could be heavy-handed. But Barson lightens the tone with almost cinematic humor, ensuring that even the most painful scenes have a slapstick edge. The ticking clock behind the wedding deadline gives the story real momentum, and while the ending is all nuptial jubilation, it is also a realistic summer's end for Ann.-Martha Baden, Prescott Public Library, AZ
Copyright 2013 School Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.
January 1, 2014
When Ann's aunt Jackie asks her to be a bridesmaid in her (lesbian) wedding, Ann resolves to lose forty-five pounds in two months. Her journey is funny and relatable--if also difficult and depressing. Barson writes with a light touch, but unflinchingly confronts stereotypes about overweight people. Ann finally understands that she isn't defined by her weight--an inspiring realization for all readers.
(Copyright 2014 by The Horn Book, Incorporated, Boston. All rights reserved.)
September 1, 2013
Sixteen-year-old Ann Galardi wants to lose weight: she can't fit into department store clothes, and her skinny, weight-obsessed mother constantly buys her smaller sizes as "incentive." But it's only when Ann's cool aunt Jackie asks her to be a bridesmaid in her (lesbian) wedding that, with dress shopping looming, Ann resolves to lose forty-five pounds in two months. Her journey is funny and relatable -- if also difficult and depressing. There's eating the weight-loss food she orders off an infomercial ("kind of grainy, kind of tomatoey, but mostly like a sponge"); embarrassing herself in front of her crush ("I hurl nasty-tasting brown liquid all over Jon's used-to-be pure white and clean Nikes"); and getting motivated to exercise ("I decide to download good running songs first. It takes a while. . .I'll run tomorrow"). Debut author Barson writes with a light touch, but unflinchingly confronts stereotypes about overweight people: an irate customer at the pretzel shop where Ann works, for example, cruelly accuses her of eating all the pretzels. The novel doesn't minimalize Ann's struggles, either, illustrating how her obsession with food is tied to her emotions and, for much of the book, her self-worth. But once she recognizes how food affects her life and that of her family, Ann finally understands that she isn't defined by her weight -- a realization that will inspire readers of any size. rachel l. smith
(Copyright 2013 by The Horn Book, Incorporated, Boston. All rights reserved.)